Clinical Cases  ·  Psychiatry I  ·  Depression
← Back to Psychiatry I
Psychiatry

Depression

25 cases on antidepressant selection, augmentation, and management across the real range of depressive disorders — choose a case below to open its full multi-voice debate.

PsychiatryDepression
Esketamine Monotherapy: Label vs. Payer Policy

Intranasal esketamine has been approvable as monotherapy since 2025 — but her payer's criteria still require a concurrent oral antidepressant, and the only dose she can tolerate may not be doing anything at all.

Case 0001→
PsychiatryDepression
TCA Selection in TRD with Suicide Risk

Tricyclics remain among the most effective drugs available for treatment-resistant depression — and among the most lethal in overdose. Two patients with the same failed history put that tradeoff on opposite ends of the same decision.

Case 0002→
PsychiatryDepression
MAOI Use in Atypical Depression

The oldest comparative trials in depression pharmacology still favor MAOIs for atypical features — the barrier to using one here isn't efficacy, it's a five-week washout and a diet most patients aren't warned is this strict.

Case 0003→
PsychiatryDepression
Bupropion with Seizure Risk + Eating-Disorder History

Bupropion's eating-disorder contraindication is absolute on the label — but the seizure signal behind it came from actively purging patients with electrolyte disturbance, not from a diagnosis sitting a decade in the past.

Case 0004→
PsychiatryDepression
Pharmacogenomic-Guided Antidepressant Selection

A combinatorial pharmacogenomic panel came back with a clean answer for why two drugs failed on side effects — the harder question is how far that same result should reach into which drug gets tried next.

Case 0005→
PsychiatryDepression
TRD Augmentation: Antipsychotic vs. Lithium vs. T3 vs. Switch

Aripiprazole, lithium, T3, and switching to a new agent are all reasonable next steps after two failed antidepressant trials — none has ever shown clear superiority over the others in a real head-to-head comparison.

Case 0006→
PsychiatryDepression
Sequencing ECT, Esketamine, and Ketamine

ECT still has the strongest response data of anything available for severe treatment-resistant depression — but this patient has already refused it, and that refusal has to shape the sequence, not just be noted and overridden.

Case 0007→
PsychiatryDepression
Maintenance Therapy vs. Supervised Discontinuation

She's eight months into remission from a first depressive episode — inside the guideline window for continuing treatment, but close enough to the edge that stopping now isn't clearly wrong either.

Case 0008→
PsychiatryDepression
Managing SSRI-Induced Sexual Dysfunction

Sertraline has kept his depression in remission for a year — the erectile and ejaculatory side effects it caused are now straining his marriage enough that stopping the drug is genuinely on the table.

Case 0009→
PsychiatryDepression
SSRI Use in Pregnancy

She stopped her antidepressant the day the pregnancy test came back positive — the relapse risk that decision carries turns out to be the bigger question than the medication ever was.

Case 0010→
PsychiatryDepression
SSRI/SNRI Use While Breastfeeding

Fluoxetine is the only antidepressant that has ever put her depression into full remission — it's also the one lactation pharmacology has the most specific reservations about.

Case 0011→
PsychiatryDepression
PMDD: Luteal-Phase-Only vs. Continuous SSRI Dosing

SSRIs act fast enough in PMDD to be dosed only in the luteal phase — a real option for a patient with predictable cycles, and a much harder one for a patient whose cycles won't reliably tell her when the luteal phase begins.

Case 0012→
PsychiatryDepression
Refractory PMDD: GnRH Agonist + Add-Back

A GnRH agonist can shut down the ovarian cycle driving her PMDD entirely — the progestin needed to protect her uterus from unopposed estrogen is the same class of hormone her PMDD may already be sensitive to.

Case 0013→
PsychiatryDepression
Postpartum Depression: Zuranolone/Brexanolone vs. SSRI

Zuranolone can lift postpartum depression within days through an entirely different mechanism than an SSRI — the obstacle isn't whether it would work, it's a payer criterion built around a drug that takes weeks.

Case 0014→
PsychiatryDepression
Post-Stroke Depression: Prophylactic vs. Treat-if-Emerges

One trial suggested prophylactic fluoxetine after stroke improves motor recovery; a much larger one found no benefit and a real fracture-risk signal. Which reading should govern depends heavily on who is actually at risk for depression in the first place.

Case 0015→
PsychiatryDepression
Depression Due to Hypothyroidism

Her TSH is high enough to warrant thyroid treatment on its own — but subclinical hypothyroidism's actual link to depression is contested enough that treating the thyroid alone is a real gamble on a four-month, functionally disabling episode.

Case 0016→
PsychiatryDepression
Steroid-Induced Depression, Can't Stop the Steroid

High-dose prednisone is the most likely cause of her new depression, and it's also the only thing currently holding a kidney-threatening flare of lupus nephritis in check — tapering it isn't an option, so the depression has to be treated around it.

Case 0017→
PsychiatryDepression
Depression in Parkinson's: SSRI/SNRI vs. Pramipexole

His selegiline makes a standard SSRI a real serotonin-syndrome consideration — a dopamine agonist could treat his mood and his motor symptoms with one drug, at the cost of a very different risk profile.

Case 0018→
PsychiatryDepression
Isotretinoin-Associated Depression

Isotretinoin's depression signal has never been cleanly separated from the psychological weight of severe acne itself — and the regulatory program everyone assumes is watching for it is watching for something else entirely.

Case 0019→
PsychiatryDepression
Beta-Blocker "Depression": Myth vs. Modern Evidence

The old teaching that beta-blockers cause depression traces to decades-old case reports that modern meta-analyses haven't replicated — but it's exactly what's making a post-MI patient hesitate to take a drug proven to reduce his mortality.

Case 0020→
PsychiatryDepression
Varenicline's Reversed Black Box Warning

The FDA removed varenicline's neuropsychiatric black box warning in 2016 after a trial specifically designed to test it in patients with her exact diagnosis — the outdated caution has outlived the evidence behind it.

Case 0021→
PsychiatryDepression
Persistent Depressive Disorder: Treatment Threshold

Nothing about her symptoms has ever looked severe enough to seem urgent at a single visit — six years of that same low-grade weight is exactly what makes the case for treating it now.

Case 0022→
PsychiatryDepression
Benzodiazepine Bridging for Anxious-Distress MDD

A short benzodiazepine bridge could cover the weeks before his SSRI takes effect on severe anxious distress — his father's alcohol use disorder is exactly the kind of family history that makes that bridge a genuine dependence risk, not just a convenience.

Case 0023→
PsychiatryDepression
Psilocybin-Assisted Therapy Ahead of Approval

Psilocybin isn't FDA-approved for depression yet, and the pathways to access it outside a clinical trial come with real gaps in medical oversight — including a real interaction with the SSRI keeping him stable enough to consider it at all.

Case 0024→
PsychiatryDepression
SSRI + NSAID/Anticoagulant Bleed Risk

She needs an antidepressant, a chronic NSAID for a bad knee, and an anticoagulant for her heart rhythm — three separately reasonable medications that stack on the exact same bleeding risk.

Case 0025→
← Back to Psychiatry I