Atropine addresses components 2, 3, and 4 (muscarinic and central nervous system). Mechanical ventilation is the only intervention that addresses all four simultaneously.
| Feature | Organophosphates | Carbamates |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Phosphorylation of active site serine | Carbamylation of active site serine |
| Aging | Yes — adduct becomes permanently resistant to pralidoxime over time | No — carbamyl adduct spontaneously hydrolyzes (30–120 min half-life) |
| Enzyme Recovery | Only with pralidoxime (before aging) or synthesis of new enzyme | Spontaneous, without antidote |
| Pralidoxime | Indicated — give early and continue 24–48 hours | Not indicated — may be harmful; enzyme recovers on its own |
| Atropine | Required — titrate to secretion drying | Required — same titration principle; dose requirements typically lower |
| Clinical Course | Potentially prolonged; redistribution from tissue stores can cause relapse | Shorter and more self-limited; symptoms typically resolve in 6–24 hours |
| Toxidrome | Full cholinergic toxidrome | Full cholinergic toxidrome (identical presentation) |